These really remind me of the Buxom Big & Healthy Lip Sticks. Those retail for $18.00 each though. I do find the e.l.f. Matte Lip Colors to be cheaper alternatives.
Description: This convenient jumbo sized lip pencil creates exact color application with twist up ease so you never have to sharpen. The pigment rich color glides on effortlessly and easily to provide long lasting matte color. The enriched Vitamin A, C & E formula moisturizes and hydrates lips for beautiful healthy looking lips.
Retail Price: $3.00
Be sure to watch the video for an up close look and live swatches!